CEO Income for P&C Insurers
Published September 23, 2025 at 10:52 AM · News Releases and Bulletins

The income of the heads of insurance companies is always controversial. Many of these executives take home millions each year. Critics say maybe a bit lower income might mean a bit lower premiums for the insurance people buy to help pay those salaries, bonuses and stock options.
Here are 2024’s five highest paid P&C insurance company CEOs:
1. Nicolas Papadopoulo, Arch Capital:
2024 compensation adjusted: $31.7 million
Increase over 2023: +347%
2. Evan Goldberg, Chubb
2024 adjusted compensation: $30.1 million
3. Thomas Wilson, Allstate
2024 adjusted compensation: $26.1 million
4. Peter Zaffino, AIG
2024 adjusted compensation: $24.6 million
5. Pareshbhai Patel, HCI Group
2024 compensation adjusted: $20.2 million
These are the executives who had the largest increases year-over-year between 2023 and 2024:
- Pareshbhai Patel, HCI Group: +461.5%
- Margaret Tooth, Trumpanion: +357%
- Nicolas Papadopoulo, Arch Capital: +347%
- Stephen Sills, Bowhead Specialty: +235.9%
- Gabriel Tirador, Mercury General: +124.5%
- Stephen Spray, Cincinnati Financial: +98.4%
- Seth Daggett, NI Holdings: +94.3%
- George Murphy, Safety Insurance: +87.5%
- Meryl Golden, Kingstone: +75.1%
- Brian Roney, Conifer Holdings: +72.9%
Source link: PropertyCasualty360.com — https://bit.ly/4mucRI2
