(888) 246-4466

Commissioner-Elect Questions California Commissioner Lara’s Sustainable Insurance Strategy

Published November 17, 2026 at 2:04 PM · News Releases and Bulletins

California Insurance Commissioner Jane Kim
California Insurance Commissioner Jane Kim

Jane Kim is set to take over as California Insurance Commissioner next year on January 4th. She plans to hit the ground running. As Weekly Industry News reported last week, Kim wants to establish a state-run disaster insurance company. If passed by the California Legislature, participation by consumers and insurers will be mandatory.

Premiums will be based on the wildfire risk for each home. It will also take into account the cost to rebuild or repair after a catastrophic loss. Reserves would be focused into mitigation measures.

Insurers would still be able to sell policies to homeowners that cover other issues, just not fire insurance.

Kim is also not that fond of current commissioner, Ricardo Lara’s Sustainable Insurance Strategy. She contends it is of more benefit to insurers than consumers.

“The Sustainable Insurance Strategy was one that was put forward as a way to appease insurers who continue to threaten to leave the state in order to raise premiums on hard working families here in California,” Kim said. “And we’re going to be examining this program and making sure that we’re also figuring out how to make insurance more affordable and more available.”

Kim also is going to look at rate filings and the approval of such filings done by Lara’s administration. She wants to make sure they are more transparent. Another issue she’s going to put under a microscope is how prompt insurers are with claims payments.

To Lara’s credit, his Sustainable Insurance Strategy has gotten insurers to again write homeowners policies. Kim thinks insurers are already making plenty of profit.

“We know they were profitable; those are the facts,” Kim said. “The data is out. They’ve been making more money than they ever have in their history the last three years. We know that they’ve been doing well.”

American Property Casualty Insurance Association (APCIA) vice president of state government affairs, Laura Curtis disagrees. She said the California Department of Insurance needs to stay the course. The effort to keep insurance companies writing policies in California is working.

“Protecting the recent progress in the market is critical. While significant challenges remain, recent reforms have begun laying the foundation for a more stable and sustainable market,” Curtis said. “Costly new mandates or regulatory actions that drive up costs or limit coverage options risk reversing this progress and worsening the crisis.”

Rex Frazier is the president of the Personal Insurance Federation of California. He agrees with Curtis and thinks Kim ought to be careful before making rash decisions about rates.

“There are clear state rules for rate review, and it is inappropriate for any state official to pre-judge an individual insurer rate filing,” Frazier said. “Arbitrary rate suppression is not only illegal, it reduces the ability of insurers to serve all communities and hurts consumers by drying up the insurance market.”

Source link: Insurance Journal — https://bit.ly/4Cacz23