Home | Print Page | Contact Us | Sign In | Join the PIA
Weekly Industry News
Blog Home All Blogs
Search all posts for:   


View all (2647) posts »

R Street’s Insurance Regulation Report Card

Posted By Administration, Tuesday, December 10, 2019

The R Street Policy Study’s 2019 Insurance Regulation Report Card has been released. R Street is a conservative nonprofit, nonpartisan public policy research group. The idea behind R Street is the promotion of free markets and limited but effective government.

The report is an annual look at insurance regulation and the effect that regulation and reforms have on insurance policies. It looks at:

  Auto insurance

  Homeowners insurance

  Residual markets

  Underwriting freedom

  And more

The only state to get an F is Louisiana. Most states — however, and at best — rate an average score. Nine states made the honor roll with an A- or above. Two of them — Arizona and Nevada — are PIA Western Alliance states. These are the states with a grade of A- or above:










One PIA Western Alliance state — California — is in the bottom tier with a D+ or lower. As noted earlier, Louisiana with an F is the worst and the others — in descending order — are:



North Dakota





North Carolina

New York

Two PIA Western Alliance states — Montana and New Mexico — are among the most improved. Florida is the most improved going from a B to an A-. As for the two PIA Western Alliance states:

Montana — D to a C-

New Mexico — B- to a B+

The PIA Western Alliance state of Oregon is among those seeing the biggest scoring drop:

Colorado — C to a D+

Maine — A- to a B

Oregon — B to a C+

In the report conclusion, R Street’s researchers said, “there are ways in which the thicket of state-by-state regulations leads to inefficiencies, as well as state policies that have the effect of discouraging capital formation, stifling competition and concentrating risk. Central among these are rate controls.”

Here are the rankings and statistics of PIA Western Alliance States. It is interesting to note that two are in the top-10 and two more are in the top 20. Two states are in the middle of the pack and two are in the bottom tier.

Here they are in order of their R Street ranking:


Rank — 6

Score — 70.3

2019 grade — A

2018 grade — A-


Strengths: Low tax and fee burden, ahead on financial exams, small residual markets

Weaknesses: None


Rank — 7

Score — 70.1

2019 grade — A

2018 grade — A


Strengths: No regulatory surplus, significant underwriting freedom

Weaknesses: Large runoff obligations, thinly capitalized markets


Rank — 12

Score — 67.9

2019 grade — B+

2018 grade — A-


Strengths: No runoff obligations, competitive auto market

Weaknesses: Very high homeowners loss ratio, large workers' compensation state fund

New Mexico

Rank — 15

Score — 67.5

2019 grade — B+

2018 grade — B-


Strengths: Low politicization, no runoff obligations

Weaknesses: High tax and fee burden, thinly capitalized markets, large workers' compensation state fund


Rank — 27

Score — 61.1

2019 grade — C+

2018 grade — B


Strengths: Low tax and fee burdens

Weaknesses: Large regulatory surplus, large workers' compensation state fund


Rank — 30

Score — 60.1

2019 grade — C+

2018 grade — C


Strengths: Ahead on financial exams, no runoff obligations

Weaknesses: Politicized market, monopoly on workers' compensation fund, little underwriting freedom, desk drawer rules


Rank — 40

Score — 55.4

2019 grade — C-

2018 grade — D


Strengths: No special strengths

Weaknesses: Politicized market, high tax and fee burdens, very high homeowners loss ratio, large workers' compensation state fund


Rank — 45

Score — 50.6

2019 grade — D

2018 grade — D


Strengths: Competitive auto market

Weaknesses: Politicized market, very high homeowners loss ratio, not much underwriting freedom, desk drawer rules, credit scoring restrictions, territorial restrictions


Rank — 46

Score — 50.2

2019 grade — D

2018 grade — D


Strengths: No runoff obligations, small residual markets

Weakness: High taxes and fees are a burden, concentrated auto and homeowners markets, little underwriting freedom


Source links: R Street — link 1, link 2


This post has not been tagged.

Share |
Permalink | Comments (0)

A special thank you to our KKlub Members for their support.